Amazon FBA vs FBM: Which Is Better for You?

When selling on Amazon, choosing the right fulfillment method is crucial for your business’s success. The two primary options are Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) and Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM). Each method has its unique advantages and disadvantages, making it essential to understand which one aligns best with your business needs.

Amazon FBA vs. FBM: Which Is Better for You

What are Amazon FBA and FBM?

Amazon FBA and FBM are two distinct fulfillment methods that sellers can use to manage their products on Amazon.

Fulfillment by Amazon

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is a service where Amazon handles storage, packaging, and shipping of products on behalf of sellers. Here are the key features of FBA:

  • Amazon Prime Eligibility: Products are eligible for Amazon Prime, offering fast shipping options.
  • Storage and Shipping: Amazon stores your products in its warehouses and manages the entire shipping process.
  • Customer Service: Amazon provides customer service and handles returns for FBA products.
  • Buy Box Advantage: FBA products often have a higher chance of winning the Buy Box.
  • Scalability: Ideal for high-volume sellers due to Amazon’s extensive logistics network.

Fulfillment by Merchant

Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) requires sellers to manage their own storage, packaging, and shipping. Here are the key features of FBM:

  • Control Over Fulfillment: Sellers have full control over their inventory and shipping processes.
  • Cost Management: Potentially lower costs as sellers avoid FBA fees.
  • Personalized Customer Service: Sellers can provide a personalized customer service experience.
  • Flexibility: Suitable for unique or oversized products that may incur high FBA fees.
  • Multi-channel Fulfillment: Allows sellers to fulfill orders from multiple sales channels.

Differences Between Amazon FBA and FBM

Here’s a comparison of FBA and FBM across various factors:

Factor

FBA

FBM

Fulfillment

Managed by Amazon

Managed by the seller

Storage

Amazon warehouses

Seller’s own storage

Shipping

Handled by Amazon

Handled by the seller

Customer Service

Provided by Amazon

Provided by the seller

Fees

Includes storage and fulfillment fees

No FBA fees, but incurs shipping costs

Control

Less control over branding and packaging

Full control over branding and packaging

Prime Eligibility

Eligible for Prime

Not eligible for Prime

Buy Box

Higher chance of winning the Buy Box

Lower chance of winning the Buy Box

Scalability

Suitable for high-volume sellers

Suitable for low-volume or niche products

Differences Between Amazon FBA and FBM

Amazon FBA and FBM Integration for Dropshipping

Integrating FBA and FBM in a dropshipping business can offer flexibility and efficiency. Here are the steps to integrate both methods:

  • Evaluate Product Types: Determine which products are better suited for FBA or FBM based on size, weight, and sales volume.
  • Set Up Both Accounts: Create both FBA and FBM accounts to manage different product lines.
  • Optimize Inventory: Use FBA for fast-moving products and FBM for slow-moving or oversized items.
  • Monitor Performance: Regularly review sales data to adjust your fulfillment strategy.
  • Leverage Multichannel Tools: Use software tools to synchronize inventory and orders across multiple sales channels.

Pros & Cons of Amazon FBA

What Are the Benefits of Using Amazon FBA in Dropshipping?

  • Prime Shipping: Access to Amazon Prime’s fast shipping options, increasing customer satisfaction.
  • Winning the Buy Box: Higher likelihood of winning the Buy Box, boosting sales.
  • Selling Focused Approach: Allows sellers to focus on marketing and product development.
  • Higher Sales: Increased visibility and sales potential due to Amazon’s logistics network.
  • Ease of Shipping: Simplifies the shipping process as Amazon handles logistics.
  • Customer Support: Amazon provides customer service, reducing the seller’s workload.
  • Multichannel Options: Ability to fulfill orders from other platforms using Amazon’s logistics.

What are the Disadvantages of Using Amazon FBA in Dropshipping?

  • High FBA Fees: Includes various fees that can impact profit margins.
  • Branding Limitations: Limited control over packaging and branding.
  • Lack of Control: Less control over inventory management and customer interaction.
  • Increased Returns: Potential for higher return rates due to Amazon’s return policies.
  • Inventory Organization Challenges: Requires careful inventory management to avoid long-term storage fees.

Pros and Cons of Amazon FBM

Benefits of Amazon FBM in Dropshipping

  • No Capacity Limits: Unlimited storage capacity as sellers manage their own inventory.
  • Personalized Customer Approach: Ability to offer personalized customer service and packaging.
  • No Amazon Long-term Storage Fees: Avoids long-term storage fees associated with FBA.
  • Freedom to Choose Your Carrier: Flexibility to select preferred shipping carriers.
  • More Extensive Geography Span: Potential to reach a broader geographic area.
  • Full Control Over Returns: Sellers manage their own return processes.

What Are the Downsides of Amazon FBM?

  • Time-consuming Preparatory Work: Requires more time and effort in managing logistics.
  • Customer Service is on You: Sellers are responsible for all customer service interactions.
  • Hurdles During Cross-border Logistics: Challenges in managing international shipping and customs.
  • Lower Chance to Win the Amazon Buy Box: Less competitive in the Buy Box compared to FBA.
  • Referral Fee and Other Expenses: Additional costs such as referral fees.
  • Tough Competition with FBA Sellers: Competes with FBA sellers who have logistical advantages.

How to Choose Between Amazon FBA vs. FBM Dropshipping?

Here’s a decision matrix to help choose between FBA and FBM:

Factor

FBA Preference

FBM Preference

Business Turnover

High turnover, large volume

Low turnover, niche products

Characteristics of Products

Standard-sized, fast-moving items

Oversized, unique, or slow-moving items

Customer Expectations

Fast shipping, Amazon Prime

Personalized service, custom packaging

Level of Control Needed

Less control over logistics

Full control over logistics and branding

FBA or FBM seller

FAQ

Is FBA better than FBM?

FBA is better for high-volume sellers seeking convenience and scalability, while FBM suits those wanting control over logistics and costs.

How can I identify an FBA or FBM seller?

FBA products often have the Prime badge, while FBM products may not. Check the shipping details on the product page for clarity.

Can I do FBA and FBM at the same time?

Yes, sellers can use both FBA and FBM simultaneously to manage different product lines and optimize fulfillment strategies.

How can I switch from FBA to FBM?

To switch from FBA to FBM, adjust your Amazon settings, update inventory management, and manage shipping processes independently.

How many products can I send to FBA?

Amazon imposes limits based on storage capacity and product type. Regularly review inventory performance to optimize storage space.

Wrapping Up

Choosing between Amazon FBA and FBM depends on your business model, product characteristics, and logistical preferences. FBA offers convenience and scalability, while FBM provides control and cost management. Aligning these options with your business goals can help you make an informed decision that enhances your Amazon selling experience.